[情報] Chelsea Janes 支持 Arcia 報導記者
https://twitter.com/chelsea_janes/status/1712612301604303148
Hey there, I’m the other reporter who reported what Arcia said in the
clubhouse Monday night. I didn’t name him because I didn’t see who
said it. But I’m sick of watching people, particularly colleagues in
the media, criticize my friend @Jake_Mintz for it. A
我也寫了一篇 Arcia 的新聞,但因為當時不確定是誰說的而沒寫出名字。
可是我對 Jake Mintz 被眾人批評感到不太舒服。
--
Cameras were rolling. Recorders were rolling. In fact, last night,
I asked Arcia if he knows recorders are rolling in the clubhouse.
He said, through his interpreter, that “there are. I don’t know
that they have to be there, but they are.”
當時記者,攝影機,錄音機都在休息室內到處亂晃。我在事件後還問
Arcia: "你有認知到記者在休息室採訪嗎?",他透過翻譯回答:
"雖然我不知道他們會在這時來採訪,但我知道他們在這"
--
1) He yelled the phrase when cameras and recorders were rolling. I
have audio. Had he done it at a slightly different moment, a
camera sending an interview live to the truck might have caught
it. Would you be eviscerating that network? Or would you say,
1. 他在記者四處訪問時說出那些字,我也錄下來了。假如你知道
攝影機現場直撥還說那些東西,難道還會罵他們不該播報嗎?
--
Shouldn’t say that with cameras around?
還是說你會檢討自己不該在攝影機前亂講話?
2) Suggesting you shouldn’t report something said in the presence
of MORE THAN A DOZEN reporters because it “wasn’t meant to get
out?” is suggesting reporters should be protecting players from
themselves. That’s not our job. It’s theirs.
2. 假如你認為就算在一大群記者前,他們也該保護球員,不要報導私下的內心話?
但這不是記者的工作,球員自己就該注意。
--
And 3) HE SAID ATTABOY HARPER. It wasn’t a slur. It wasn’t
hateful. It was trash talk and the only reason anyone cares that
it got out is because they know it would motivate Harper to beat
them. Which implies the Braves do not feel they can handle a
motivated Bryce Harper and are
3. 他只是說了:"好樣的" 垃圾話。並不是貶低他,也不是仇恨。
只因為你不希望他受到挑釁就不該報導? 那是不是代表勇士害怕因為 Harper
--
Willing to suggest that is why they lost the other day. Otherwise,
why not laugh it off? And frankly, shouldn’t everyone in the
Atlanta clubhouse have far greater concerns after an 10-2 loss
than whether Bryce Harper is mad at their shortstop? They lost by
8!
被挑釁後全力全開而輸球?不然幹嘛這麼在意這報導?
而且比起 Harper 抓狂,勇士更應該擔心他們 10-2 輸了8 分!
--
I didn’t say something sooner because I thought this was
overblown. And frankly, I thought it wouldn’t help. But I am
genuinely disgusted by the way some media members are acting like
a reporter was in the wrong for this. He wasn’t.
我不會再對這炒過頭的事件發表意見,而且我認為這樣也沒幫助。
但我覺得站在反對報導那方的媒體讓人不舒服。
--
And if the Braves let this be the story of their series, that’s
on them. Win and it goes away. Period.
假如勇士認為休息室的報導規範很重要,那就這樣吧。
但為什麼不趕快贏得系列賽讓一切煙消雲散呢?
Jon Heyman 也贊同他:
https://twitter.com/JonHeyman/status/1712646163906621638
Very Worthwhile thread. I’m amazed media people r criticizing a
reporter for reporting what was said in front of many reporters.
He’s supposed to guess the player wanted it heard but not
reported? Plus, this seemed to only become regrettable after
Harper responded with 2 homers!
為什麼要批評球員在記者前的講話被寫成報導呢?
難道我們要讀心判斷哪些該報導,哪些不該?
而且他們好像在 Harper 打了雙響炮才後悔,
而不是報導出來就後悔!
--
刺客記者美國版?
學鼓人直接把費城人打爆不就好了 出頭一堆
這跟台媒刺客完全不一樣,記者那時候能在休息室晃找
球員訪問
rosenthal也支持他
切爾西
有本事自己尻兩支反擊
標準輸不起,被打爆才哭哭
看成Chipper Jones
Arcia的回應真的不行 多講多錯…
記者並沒有違規 更何況你有意識到有人在 嘴巴還那
麼大 而重點更在 把費城炸爛就沒這些事情了 但並沒
有
看來也知道有媒體故意嘲諷大聲的喔 被打爆才哭哭
是媒體拱火沒錯,但還在可以接受程度
敗人品囉
有實力就自己炸兩隻 下去放假嘍
輸不起 哭哭
其實他也沒有貶低 然後被報出去之後就被塑造成敗人品
順便問,這篇可以借轉到MLB版嗎?
@Fitzwilliam OK
10/13 12:58
感謝,想說提供另一方見解
宇宙勇 下去!
70
[分享] Orlando Arcia嗆費城球迷在嘲諷Harper被記者流出之後跟費城球迷槓上的Arcia 今天在休息區板凳跟球迷吵架 一下嘲諷球迷沒有戒指,一下大聲嗆聲,一下扮鬼臉,直到Acuna制止才停下,但早就被錄起68
[炸裂] Bryce Harper國家聯盟分區系列賽第三戰 亞特蘭大勇士跟費城費城人的比賽 來到五局下半 費城人打者 Harper 棒打勇士中繼投手Hand 是一發中外野方向的陽春全壘打 個人單場雙響砲 勇士1:7費城人42
[花邊] Iguodala:面對灰熊時,勇士記者發假新聞Iguodala:面對灰熊時,勇士記者發布假新聞 Cyrus Saatsaz, 另一個勇士記者XD Here’s @andre saying on his podcast that when @kendra__andrews33
[情報] Orlando Arcia不滿休息室言論被媒體外傳Orlando Arcia isn't happy that the "atta boy Harper" quote left the clubhouse Orlando Arcia對於他在第二戰賽後於休息室嘲諷哈波的言論 被媒體報導出來感到不太開心28
[情報] 當年原已談妥的Harper交易案(國民-鼓人)休士頓紀事報記者Chandler Rome 今天報導揭露了2018年,太空人差一點交易來Bryce Harper的細節 Here is how the Astros nearly acquired Bryce Harper in 2018, complete with the f ull trade package Jeff Luhnow and Mike Rizzo agreed upon before Nationals owners28
[情報] 當年原已談妥的Harper交易案(國民-鼓人)休士頓紀事報記者Chandler Rome 今天報導揭露了2018年,太空人差一點交易來Bryce Harper的細節 Here is how the Astros nearly acquired Bryce Harper in 2018, complete with the f ull trade package Jeff Luhnow and Mike Rizzo agreed upon before Nationals owners27
[情報] 今日Bryce Harper/ Noah Syndergaard今日Bryce Harper 國聯分區系列戰G4 擔任費城人隊第四棒指定打擊 AB:5 R:114
[情報] Gausman:記者不該把休息室聽到的東西寫藍鳥王牌投手Kevin Gausman在個人推特上 對於這次Arica風波表達意見 It’s ridiculous us players have to watch what we say in OUR clubhouse1
[討論] Bryce Harper太神了吧 雙響砲 暴打勇士一頓 --
爆
[情報] 台鋼雄鷹大巨蛋主場入場贈品+主題球衣爆
[分享] 黃勇傳選手合約讓渡公告與結果(更新:5/2爆
[情報] CPBL 5/23球員異動90
[分享] 柳田悠岐教你如何成超一流打者秘訣78
[情報] CPBL明日先發投手56
[分享] 大谷翔平在休息室差點被球打到&反應40
Re: [情報] 台鋼雄鷹大巨蛋主場入場贈品+主題球衣39
[分享] 今日 大谷翔平36
[分享] 「爪爪實況慶典」中信兄弟x實況野球主題35
[情報] 富邦悍將大巨蛋主場入場+餐飲攤位資訊33
[舊聞] XBX-看學弟潘武雄引退賽 43歲高國慶超想打51
[情報] 韓職開始討論亞洲外援制度25
[分享] 今日Aaron Judge22
[情報] 樂天應援毛巾開賣12
[分享] 今日 Corbin Carroll62
[討論] 所以新的經紀公司到底要幹嘛爆
[討論] 想打球怎麼不接統一電話?14
Re: [情報] 韓職開始討論亞洲外援制度12
[情報] NPB 5/24 預告先發 (佐々木朗希)2X
[分享] 自刪33
[情報] 統一獅FB-獅子軍變臉小公仔 加價購9
[分享] Max Fried 五局低調中10
[分享] 井口資仁將幫軟銀開球10
[分享] 今日 Andrew Benintendi 0-410
[分享] 費城人前50場36勝14敗自2001年以來最佳10
[分享] 今日Max Fried 完投勝8
[分享] KBO:亞洲名額 時機未到9
[討論] MLB投手減少投快速球更能有效壓制打者?34
[分享] 遊騎兵藍色的粥影片