Re: [閒聊] 郭天信v.s林哲瑄

撇開其他問題不談

林哲瑄的機體在守備是最頂的

頂到同時期連MLB的正CF可能不超過20個比他好

我可以保證當時NYY的Granderson判斷還沒蝦好

比較接近的應該是Gardner但蝦的Arm比他好兩個等級

對，MLB一樣一堆CF是靠打擊在守，正CF守備就是這麼難

舉例來說最明顯的例子，一朗在MLB的CF守備能力是略低於平均水準

所以光論守備，蝦機體天賦能力的評價不下一朗

郭天信判斷雖然不算差，但光中職目前岳政跟宋88可能就比他略好一點了

林政華跟申浩瑋應該也跟他差不多同水準

只能說蝦的超爛揮棒跟守中線快速退化的糗樣給人印象跟他全盛時期一樣深刻

不然光守備中職目前還沒人能摸到全盛時期他的地板

Che-Hsuan Lin

Scouting Report: Medium build, without much more room to fill out. Solid

athlete. Compact, level swing through the hitting zone. Not much leverage or

upward plane in swing. Generates fringe-average batspeed. Above-average

approach and pitch recognition. Excels at working counts. Rarely chases

offerings outside of his strike zone. Shows bat control to spoil tough

pitches, hang deep into counts, and get bat on the ball. Struggles to square

up pitches. Can struggle with balance at plate. Swing requires maintenance.

Creates infrequent instances of backspin, with a lot of

contact resulting in weak grounders or flares. Below-average hit tool. Does

not barrel enough balls up to produce average batting averages at the major

league level. Well below-average power projection. Plus speed. Ability to

steal 20 bases in the big leagues. Well-above average defender. Possesses

outstanding defensive instincts. Seems to get a head start on balls off the

bat. Covers excellent ground from

gap-to-gap. Plus-plus arm, with improving accuracy. Projects as a bench

player at the major league level, with emphasis on role as defensive

replacement/pinch runner.

預估MLB 20盜的速度 + 傑出的防守判斷 + 最頂的手臂 整體水準高於MLB平均

但打擊只有選球高於平均 + contact OK但仰角低 整體水準低於MLB平均

真要說最像的其實是宋88 不過88當初被擔憂的打擊看起來應該優於中職平均沒問題

可喜可賀

--
中華職棒七大不可思議
1.要保護投手但傷癒復出要控制局數的Top Prospect，季中SPRP定位亂調
2.投手腳受傷手有持續在動所以沒差 3.低階聯盟OPS+70的一壘手在美國就是游擊砲4.RP一年丟快100局 5.RP熱了不用浪費所以大比分還是要上
6.不愛用的球員離職宣稱球員有未來方向是好事
7.這隊偷了一個總冠軍

--