Re: [討論] 觸發review投籃是否踩線的條件?

最終版本(應該是)

https://official.nba.com/rule-no-13-instant-replay/

官方規則 IRS條例
其中
Section I—Instant Replay Review Triggers

觸發IRS的條件

其中
6.Officials are not reasonably certain at any time during a game whether (i) a successful field goal was scored correctly as a 2-point or 3-point field goal, or (ii) in the case of a called shooting foul, whether the player was
attempting a 2-point or 3-point field goal; provided that the Replay Center Official did not trigger instant replay to review these matters as permitted by Section I-b(1)

白話就是

裁判在任何時候沒辦法確定是兩分或三分時都可以看重播
或是被犯規時沒辦法確定(略)

這邊會有個疑問
因為這球基本上沒有兩分的空間
怎麼會符合啟動條件

因為

Section II—Reviewable Matters

他寫在下面了
可檢查的事項
其中f項提到

f.If an instant replay review is triggered as described in Section I-a(6) above, the Replay Center Official and on-court official(s) would review the video to determine the following issues:

如果因為Section I-a(6)(就是上面說的那條)
啟動IRS 則可以檢查
其中第三點

3.If the shot was timely, whether the shooter committed a boundary line
violation or the ball touched out-of-bounds prior to entering the basket or, in the case of a foul, whether the player fouled committed a boundary line
violation. For purposes of this review, the Replay Center Official would look only at the position of the player’s feet at the moment they last touched the floor immediately prior to (or, if applicable, during) the release of the
shot or the foul (as applicable).

如果出手即時(就是沒有超過時間啦)
投籃者是否犯規或球進網前觸及邊線(略)

所以是可以的

至於為什麼啟動條件沒寫到
但啟動後可以檢視

窩不知道 我英文不好

但總之就是
看起來引用這條來看踩線應該是一種常態且可被接受的

只是字面上看起來好像怪怪的而已

--

沒有搞自己 就我常講的那個例子 金塊對應該是小牛 第二節末對手三分踩線 中場休息完 回來才說扣三分 時間倒回第二節0.2秒 然後被金塊投進Logo shot 慶祝五秒開始第三節比賽 這就是一個一樣沒call然後大概是引用6的例子

II是改判原則 如果是f那就是引用6 我是感覺用6檢視怪怪的 因為那球就沒有兩分的空間 字面上也只有判定2/3分球沒有給你判定0分出界 阿裁判說是就是吧 也不是說不過去的事

whether a called out-of-bounds in fact occurred during the last two minutes of the fourth period or last two minutes of any overtime period(s). 沒看反吧? 吧? 最後兩分鐘要Call才能看阿(然後後面說被取消了)

欸 不是 字面上是說隨時可以觸發

等一下 你是對的 但我先 拉個肚子

修正了 7確實跟"判定出界"無關 是"判定出界後"的事 那就變得很玄吶

對 是挑戰球權 不是挑戰有沒有出界 阿只是 挑戰球權就會伴隨是誰先出界/違例這種事

沒 就還是要看啟動條件 能啟動的才能啟動