[情報] 美國法院駁回Nerlens Noel控告Rich Paul案

k1230588 發表於 2022/9/15 上午11:09:12

看板NBA標題[情報] 美國法院駁回Nerlens Noel控告Rich Paul案作者

(恆秋)時間Sep 15 11:09:12 2022推噓35 推:37 噓:2 →:29

內容：

Pistons center Nerlens Noel had his lawsuit against agent Rich Paul and
Klutch Sports Group dismissed Tuesday. In her ruling, Dallas-based district
court judge Jane J. Boyle sent the case to the NBPA’s arbitration system to
be resolved.

Noel initially sued Paul and his agency in the summer of 2021 in hopes of
recouping some of the money he alleged he lost out in contracts over the
course of his career due to, he says, a lack of proper representation by the
Klutch Sports agent.

In dismissing the case, Boyle wrote in her order: “In sum, the Court has
determined that a valid, enforceable agreement to arbitrate exists between
the parties.”

In the initial lawsuit, Noel alleged that Paul “did little to no work” to
secure contracts, pitch teams and land endorsement deals on Noel’s behalf
while the player was represented by Paul.

Noel’s attorneys also argued that the center lost out on a four-year, $70
million deal with the Mavericks after the 2016-17 season on advice from Paul
and “was instead forced to sign a series of qualifying offers and league
minimum contracts which were well below the true value of Noel’s services in
the NBA marketplace.”

Knicks center Nerlens Noel sued Rich Paul. But his target is now the NBPA

After turning down that initial deal in 2017, Noel signed a shorter, smaller
deal to return to Dallas and then followup short deals with Oklahoma City in
2018 and New York in 2020. In 2021, he signed a three-year, $27.77 million
deal with the Knicks and then was traded to the Pistons in the summer of 2022.

活塞中鋒Nerlens Noel日前與前經紀團隊Rich Paul和Klutch Sports的
訴訟，已於美國時間周二遭到達拉斯法院的駁回。

於該訴訟中，Noel團隊主張Klutch Sports原先保證可以為他獲得70M/4yr
的合約，而最終由於Klutch Sports的不作為，導致最終他只能簽下1年
的QO，以及後續低於自己身價的複數年合約。

法官Jane J. Boyle認為，Klutch Sports團隊並未強迫Noel團隊簽訂合
約，且合約內容並無不合理之處。

補充一下，其實目前判決還沒定讞
最新進度是法官也把該案送去NPBA協會
預計在那邊的協調會再有一波攻防
但是情況看起來對Noel很不利

我應該在車裡，不應該在車底

※ PTT留言評論

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 126.159.26.52 (日本)

※ PTT 網址

推

ooplus 09/15 11:11這可以說法院認證吧

推

Kazmier 09/15 11:11這種本來就很難告贏波

→

Kazmier 09/15 11:11吧

推

EMSOK 09/15 11:11這要怎麼告贏

推

liusim 09/15 11:13其實這個新聞只有單方面的表述富堡那邊都沒說話？

→

liusim 09/15 11:13傳出要告就一直是NOEL這邊的說法

推

f77928 09/15 11:14查無不法謝謝指教

※ 編輯: k1230588 (126.159.26.52 日本), 09/15/2022 11:16:18

→

ooxxman 09/15 11:15最後是自己選的，高估情勢判斷失誤，虧慘了德軟前輩

→

Despairile 09/15 11:16法院應該只是告知他"他想告的這些部分" 法上無違法?

→

Despairile 09/15 11:16除非能證明做決定的不是自己不然沒啥勝算吧?

→

kixer2005 09/15 11:18簽約都要包贏喔？那經紀約不提高個10倍說不過去

推

ijk77692 09/15 11:20好險小犢沒有簽下來

→

Chanlin01 09/15 11:20這咖也是笑死有運鈔車不搭跑去搭類火車

→

Bashar 09/15 11:2417年的四年70M 讓我想到德軟

推

Kazmier 09/15 11:25 Noel不是說富堡在沒告知情況下推掉某隊報價

→

Kazmier 09/15 11:25價

推

gm79227922 09/15 11:25這個能成德軟可以爽拿很多錢

推

kacaoy 09/15 11:25不都是自己選的嗎......還是被槍壓著頭簽的

推

JayFans0610 09/15 11:28我記得他是先拒絕報價，才跟Rich Paul簽約的吧

→

gm79227922 09/15 11:28Noel那個也是自己說的看起來法院沒採信

推

karta328 09/15 11:29Noel後來是被完全放生吧但是那張70M合約又不是富保

→

karta328 09/15 11:29談的

推

Kazmier 09/15 11:30其實黑人大都是身邊的好友和親戚在亂出餿主意啦

→

Kazmier 09/15 11:30大概是亂聽親友餿主意後現在才在後悔

噓

firemm444 09/15 11:33連富寶都沒辦法幫你喬大約的話代表你真的...

推

glay7566 09/15 11:36小牛感謝你的不簽之恩

推

f77928 09/15 11:39想想連巨星的舅舅哥哥媽媽老婆之類的話都敢比球

→

f77928 09/15 11:39員還多一般家族出了個搖錢樹私下意見不得一大堆

推

evangelew 09/15 11:40因為Noel那時候爭取的是頂薪合約吧

推

ChinaKlay 09/15 11:43那約沒簽真的太傻了

推

lctns1234 09/15 11:51Rich Paul對球員已經很好了

推

HSKAO 09/15 11:58要不要簽約最後還是球員自己要決定啊

→

HSKAO 09/15 12:01又沒人能逼你簽或不簽

推

tomoti 09/15 12:03即便有錄音檔富保羅叫你不要簽會幫你簽更大都難贏吧

噓

k22015987 09/15 12:13自己沒簽然後越想越不對勁可憐哪

推

aktwophg795009/15 12:19要怎麽證明是經紀公司的不作為導致他簽不到大約

推

dwiee 09/15 12:32我記的他是先拒絕合約辭掉前經紀人才和富保簽約

→

dwiee 09/15 12:33前經紀人一直叫他快簽結果他想拿更多的約

推

hanslins 09/15 12:35如果他的意思是富保曾經跟他講70M／4 年太少了，給

→

hanslins 09/15 12:35我談能談更多？但你要有證據啊！

推

dwiee 09/15 12:37這要怎麼證明阿如果他真有那身價之後不會一直低薪

推

babyalley 09/15 13:03又一個法院認證？？

推

azlbf 09/15 13:05他的意思應該是被富堡的話術騙所以他拒絕合約然後

→

azlbf 09/15 13:05開除經紀人改跟富堡簽約

→

azlbf 09/15 13:05其實這種事情在台灣房屋仲介天天發生

→

EZ78 09/15 13:05這種東西就很難蒐證

推

SeanR 09/15 13:11法院富寶幫開的啦

推

idlewolf 09/15 13:23運鈔車都開來你面前了自己不上車的事後在那哭喔

推

possible322 09/15 13:42自己放棄簽約自以為能頂薪哭哭一堆這種咖

→

SCLPAL 09/15 13:47諾要證明富寶開保證+他又不動作導致能簽的大約飛了

→

SCLPAL 09/15 13:50不過法官想法這邊,那假設諾只收到小約然後都不簽

→

SCLPAL 09/15 13:50能贏嗎?還是又回到沒逼你簽這點

推

leosu810229 09/15 14:07重點你還是簽約了...

推

hanslins 09/15 14:08我身邊就有例子，一個仲介問屋主你租人房租多少？

→

hanslins 09/15 14:08然後跟他講比行情價便宜太多，他有客戶想要租這邊

→

hanslins 09/15 14:08，房租多少，結果屋主就直接跟只，租客講我要漲租

→

hanslins 09/15 14:08金，租客負擔不起退租，結果問房仲他的客人不租了

→

hanslins 09/15 14:08！只好空半年等

推

stja 09/15 15:47

推

kobryan 09/15 15:54你至少吃到了達拉斯熱狗

推

essential01509/15 16:29NN沒辦法證明自己能簽下更大張的約敗訴很正常

推

Anyotw 09/15 16:47談判要包贏喔= =

→

sky0158 09/15 19:05場均從未超過10分,當自己是小蟲啊?這樣能拿頂薪才怪

→

ooplus 09/15 23:30貪婪寫作素材+1

推

MG1211 09/16 10:52想不到富堡會有不幫簽大約的可能性欸能賺一定想辦

→

MG1211 09/16 10:52法賺的吧？

推

GBF8U572 09/16 11:38應該是不想幫助我皇所以被棄用很合理

推

cominlin 09/19 15:46感謝富保羅幫小牛省下一大筆

其他人也閱讀了

PTT 熱門相關