Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝
※ 引述《NKN (99%是眼鏡與吐槽)》之銘言：
: 不知道這教授用來參考的28場海戰是哪幾場
原始文章為Bigger Fleets Win
https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2023/january/bigger-fleets-win
28場海戰參考表如下
https://i.imgur.com/NTYSpVJ.jpg
拜占庭-維京/斯拉夫/阿拉伯人
葡萄牙-馬穆魯克/土耳其
英國-其他
I’ve heard a lot of people saying recently, ‘Quantity has a quality all its
own.’ And I just want to be clear: No, it doesn’t.
..not only does quantity have a quality all its own, but it also almost alwaysproves decisive in naval warfare when professional competence is equal.
數量不僅僅能代表素質
並在雙方素質相當時 扮演決定性的角色
When professional naval competence and strategic acumen were equal, the
larger fleet usually won, even when the smaller fleet possessed technologicaladvantages at the start of the conflict.
A primary reason is that technological advantages were inevitably short-lived.
即使較小的艦隊在技術上有優勢
最終往往仍是較大的艦隊獲得勝利
因技術優勢的時間往往很短暫
Inspired by Professor Hughes’ work, my decades of research have brought me
to this conclusion: In a naval struggle between near-peers, mass (numbers),
and the ability to replace losses bests technological advantage.
教授的研究指出 實力相當的海軍
數量和彌補損失的能力 勝過 技術優勢
有趣的觀點 大家可以看看
--
美軍：元老院 給我錢
元老院: 好喔，就造個一萬艘三桅槳帆船，便宜～
你們那個什麼相位陣列VLS就不用啦，技術優勢不久嘛
USN：元老院給我第七艦隊可以單挑瓷器艦隊的錢
造多點ASM啦
最後一句翻譯錯 雙反面
這些戰鬥優勢沒有直接證明c4isr
對現代有用的海軍不重要
那伊朗海軍完勝美國了...快艇數量爆多...
嗯….用跳幫時代的海戰當範例？？？這不是反串嗎？
C4ISR不是能讓帝國海軍更容易叫隊友來gank嘛？
x國海軍：吸~奶~（史丹利叫法
不知道人力划槳跟風帆戰艦時代的C4ISR是啥
最後依據完全翻譯錯誤
最後一句翻錯了
我有問題C4SIR在近代跟古戰役影響力應該遠不如現代
而單純看重情報跟指揮吧
阿 你最後一句錯了
沒辦法回文章。甲午戰爭就是以少勝多、以弱戰強。
拜占庭火戰船和葡萄牙火炮戰船都有加成XD
美國海軍太弱，要再加強一點
可能ㄧ場決勝負而非總數
第2次與第三次英荷海戰，明明都是荷蘭贏，而且荷蘭
艦隊的規模是略小於英國
大艦巨砲時代這些海戰史都是軍備競賽，瘋狂造艦的立
論根據，到21世紀，還來這套！
搞得好像人類第一次系統化研究海戰勝敗關鍵一樣！
台灣買400枚魚叉不夠就1000枚啊 台灣本身就是不沈
航母 所缺就是反擊的各式武器彈藥
X
整個方向錯了 美國最錯就是不敢堂而皇之的做侵略者 如果怕中國做船比美國快，那更應該在中國沒有藍海艦隊時 直接將中國艦隊送到太平洋底比較快 只要中國人不可以再有自己的工業，25
不知道這教授用來參考的28場海戰是哪幾場 但可以舉一些比較現代的案例 1943年3月2日-3月4日 俾斯麥海海戰 日本海軍出動8艘驅逐艦，8艘運兵船![Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f2/A20BismarckSea.jpg "Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝")
28
Bigger Fleets Win一文出自美國海軍戰爭學院未來戰爭研究所所長Sam J. Tangredi之筆 ，其知名著作為Anti-Access Warfare: Countering A2/AD Strategies，是美國對中、伊 朗反介入/區域拒止戰略的一本重要書籍。 本文Bigger Fleets Win雖不長，但仍是一篇結構脈絡完整的文章，在此逐節摘述以說明 Sam到底要表達甚麼![Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝](https://www.usni.org/sites/default/files/styles/open_graph/public/ASPP-PRO-1-23%20Hero_0.jpg?itok=-b8duRuE "Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝")
爆
[爆卦] 川哥白宮發言超譯"This is without question the latest news conference I’ve ever had,” he told supporters to chants of “USA, USA”. 川哥:媽的法克 還有人有意見嗎? 支持者: USA.USA…. “I want to thank the American people for their tremendous support. Millions![[爆卦] 川哥白宮發言超譯](https://i.imgur.com/bYcDKWEb.jpg "[爆卦] 川哥白宮發言超譯")
80
[情報] Nadal退出溫網跟東奧Hi all, not something I like to write but wanted to inform you guys that I have decided not to participate at this year’s Championships at Wimbledon and the O lympic Games in Tokyo. It’s never an easy decision to take but after listening to my body and discuss it with my team I understand that it is the right decision with the goal to prol77
[花邊] Dwight Howard 公開邀請球迷一起吃火鍋來源：魔獸 Dwight Howard IG Reading this letter almost brought me to tears just to know that I have left this type of impact on a fan’s life to the point where they can give me advice and show me support for everything that I have done in this game![[花邊] Dwight Howard 公開邀請球迷一起吃火鍋](https://scontent.cdninstagram.com/v/t51.29350-15/316992831_173218782057675_4909941501437903115_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpg_s640x640&_nc_cat=101&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=8ae9d6&_nc_ohc=F6uRAtynDPsAX_lw3aU&_nc_ht=scontent.cdninstagram.com&oh=00_AfDHFgV2xvWNzE014w3ZZVwRzzII3kZKods6XRwy2c8Kpw&oe=6386C470 "[花邊] Dwight Howard 公開邀請球迷一起吃火鍋")
36
[閒聊] Neil:人們需要教育The Last Of Us 2's Neil Druckmann Has Message For Internet Haters Gamespot把Reggie採訪Neil的大意截取了出來 Also in the interview, Druckmann said he's been speaking with Chernobyl writer Craig Mazin about this topic. They are currently working together on the HBO TV![[閒聊] Neil:人們需要教育](https://www.gamespot.com/a/uploads/screen_kubrick/1593/15930215/3534495-the-last-of-us-part-ii-e3-2018-screen-31-ps4-us-10jul18.jpg "[閒聊] Neil:人們需要教育")
66
[情報] RUS to MGPgeorgerussell63 It's official. Next year, I'll be a Mercedes F1 driver. This is a special day for me personally and professionally, but also a day of mixed emotions. I'm excited and humbled to be joining![[情報] RUS to MGP](https://scontent.cdninstagram.com/v/t51.29350-15/241302381_172951661581304_6532267807672662899_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpg_s640x640&_nc_cat=104&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=8ae9d6&_nc_ohc=QAwv8fDx19MAX90VqD7&_nc_ht=scontent.cdninstagram.com&oh=00_AfDBcokCVhNhLkM0Rcv58iNUmDY400M-QmLBdWIA9FN0ow&oe=637789E8 "[情報] RUS to MGP")
11
[閒聊] 林書豪IG穿上富邦勇士球衣jlin7 的大頭貼照 jlin7 Imo theres 3 types of people: 1. The lazy type. Which Id say dont live w the regret of not becoming the best version of yourself. Aka get off yo![[閒聊] 林書豪IG穿上富邦勇士球衣](https://scontent.cdninstagram.com/v/t51.29350-15/121668172_268165057841781_7475773712070887973_n.jpg?stp=dst-jpg_s640x640&_nc_cat=103&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=8ae9d6&_nc_ohc=dn4aDyBIFDMAX9Z4rAk&_nc_ht=scontent.cdninstagram.com&oh=00_AfBg9zlOP4J0oeVJRoprJ6WCKcNWBC0zQ7z1BZGrwrYcKw&oe=6365FEF5 "[閒聊] 林書豪IG穿上富邦勇士球衣")
4
[情報] 石頭FB/IG更新What is a dream, and what is reality? These questions always occur in my mind. I ask myself, are dreams, and reality, absolute or relative? Could we actually realise whether we are in a dream or not? I still have no answer yet, but I have luckily had an opportunity to work with![[情報] 石頭FB/IG更新](https://img.youtube.com/vi/srqdcZC2mWs/mqdefault.jpg "[情報] 石頭FB/IG更新")
![[討論] 對付綠鬣蜥 用.22LR還是用氣槍比較好](https://img.youtube.com/vi/4iLKEFM29NI/mqdefault.jpg "[討論] 對付綠鬣蜥 用.22LR還是用氣槍比較好")
![[情報] T-90M創下最高砲塔噴飛記錄](https://i.imgur.com/KwbtaaQb.jpg "[情報] T-90M創下最高砲塔噴飛記錄")
![Re: [討論] Magpul FMG9 概念設計 重出江湖](https://img.youtube.com/vi/e_eSCF17nMw/mqdefault.jpg "Re: [討論] Magpul FMG9 概念設計 重出江湖")
![[情報] 烏軍官方殲敵統計&情報數則 (24/11/23)](https://scontent-tpe1-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/467893685_919466500366429_5173333366817888614_n.jpg?cstp=mx1080x1350&ctp=p600x600&_nc_cat=1&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=cae128&_nc_ohc=9AMKsCWK-iEQ7kNvgHHErj-&_nc_zt=23&_nc_ht=scontent-tpe1-1.xx&_nc_gid=A43kI0zG2MduuxR9rQFoXgK&oh=00_AYDzx6xWgOdqQeZ6lUPW3dCKO4A73Ql1Kik3odNcM1n9mw&oe=67476221 "[情報] 烏軍官方殲敵統計&情報數則 (24/11/23)")