Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝

saccharomyce 發表於 2023/1/19 下午3:00:34

看板Military標題Re: [新聞]美海軍專家：艦隊規模更大的解放軍恐獲勝作者

(酵公菌)時間Jan 19 15:00:34 2023推噓12 推:13 噓:1 →:16

※ 引述《NKN (99%是眼鏡與吐槽)》之銘言：
: 不知道這教授用來參考的28場海戰是哪幾場

原始文章為Bigger Fleets Win
https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2023/january/bigger-fleets-win

28場海戰參考表如下
https://i.imgur.com/NTYSpVJ.jpg

海軍以小勝大只有三次：
拜占庭-維京/斯拉夫/阿拉伯人
葡萄牙-馬穆魯克/土耳其
英國-其他

I’ve heard a lot of people saying recently, ‘Quantity has a quality all its
own.’ And I just want to be clear: No, it doesn’t.

..not only does quantity have a quality all its own, but it also almost alwaysproves decisive in naval warfare when professional competence is equal.

數量不僅僅能代表素質

並在雙方素質相當時扮演決定性的角色

When professional naval competence and strategic acumen were equal, the
larger fleet usually won, even when the smaller fleet possessed technologicaladvantages at the start of the conflict.

A primary reason is that technological advantages were inevitably short-lived.

即使較小的艦隊在技術上有優勢

最終往往仍是較大的艦隊獲得勝利

因技術優勢的時間往往很短暫

Inspired by Professor Hughes’ work, my decades of research have brought me
to this conclusion: In a naval struggle between near-peers, mass (numbers),
and the ability to replace losses bests technological advantage.

教授的研究指出實力相當的海軍

數量和彌補損失的能力勝過技術優勢

有趣的觀點大家可以看看

※ PTT 留言評論

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 220.128.223.151 (臺灣)

※ PTT 網址

推

alexott 01/19 15:02美軍：元老院給我錢

推

CGT 01/19 15:05元老院: 好喔，就造個一萬艘三桅槳帆船，便宜～

→

CGT 01/19 15:06你們那個什麼相位陣列VLS就不用啦，技術優勢不久嘛